ToolAtlas listing policy
Every listing on ToolAtlas must meet this policy, when it's submitted and while it's live. Each rule has a reason code, which we give you with any decision that uses it.
What ToolAtlas lists
ToolAtlas lists software tools: web apps, SaaS products, desktop and mobile apps, browser extensions, developer tools, APIs, plugins and open-source projects that people can use, buy or download.
A listing must be for one tool. The vendor must be the business that makes it or is authorized to sell it.
Must be true of every listing
| Code | Rule | Normally |
|---|---|---|
NotSoftware | The listing is for a software tool. Not accepted: services (agencies, consulting, freelancers), courses, ebooks, physical products, marketplaces of services, blogs, news sites, and directories or "best tools" lists themselves. | Decline |
SiteUnavailable | The website loads over HTTPS with a valid certificate, returns a working page, and is not "coming soon", "under construction" or a waitlist with no product. | Changes |
Mismatch | The website is what the listing says it is: the name, description, category and pricing in the listing match the site. | Changes |
RedirectOffDomain | The listed URL doesn't redirect to a different domain. Redirects within the same site (for example example.com to www.example.com) are fine. A link through a tracker, shortener or affiliate network is not. | Changes |
Misleading | Descriptions, screenshots and claims are accurate. No fake reviews, invented user counts or awards, fake urgency, or claims to be "the #1" or "official" without basis. No use of another company's name or logo to suggest a connection that doesn't exist. | Changes, or Decline if deliberate |
BadMedia | The logo and screenshots are of this tool, are legible and contain no text or images that would break this policy. | Changes |
WrongCategory | The category and tags fit the tool. | Changes |
NotEnglish | The website has an English version, and the listing is written in English. Other languages may be offered as well. | Changes |
Duplicate | The tool isn't already listed. If an editor's basic listing exists, claim it instead. Several listings may share one vendor, not one tool. | Changes |
Never accepted
| Code | Rule | Normally |
|---|---|---|
SexualContent | Pornography, sexual services, sexually explicit content, "adult" or NSFW tools (including AI image or chat tools sold for sexual content), and sites that link prominently to any of these. The same website can never be submitted again. | Decline (permanent) |
Malware | Malware, spyware, stalkerware, credential stealers, cracked software, tools to evade security or anti-cheat, and sites that try to install anything without consent. The same website can never be submitted again. | Decline (permanent) |
ScamDeceptive | Scams, phishing, impersonation of another business, get-rich-quick or "guaranteed income" schemes, fake or clone sites, and pyramid or multi-level marketing tools. | Decline |
Gambling | Gambling, betting, casinos, lotteries and sweepstakes, and tools built to promote them. | Decline |
IllegalGoods | Drugs, weapons, weapon parts, counterfeit goods, and tools to buy or sell them. | Decline |
Piracy | Piracy, torrent indexes for copyrighted content, paywall or DRM removal, account sharing or resale, and tools to download content against the source's terms. | Decline |
Hate | Content that attacks people for their race, ethnicity, religion, disability, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or similar, or that promotes violence or extremism. | Decline |
Harassment | Tools for doxxing, surveillance of people without consent, harassment, or scraping personal data to target individuals. | Decline |
Spam | Tools whose main purpose is spam: bulk unsolicited messaging, fake engagement (followers, likes, reviews), link farms, private blog networks, or mass-generated low-quality content to manipulate search engines. | Decline |
ParkedDomain | Parked or for-sale domains, and pages with only ads or affiliate links. | Decline |
Unlawful | Anything else illegal where ATBI operates (the United States), or that infringes someone's rights. | Decline |
Allowed, with care
| Area | What's needed |
|---|---|
| AI tools | Allowed. They must not be built for sexual content, impersonation (voice or face cloning of real people without consent), academic cheating presented as such, or fake reviews. |
| Crypto and finance tools | Allowed for software (wallets, accounting, analytics, tax tools). Not for promoting tokens, trading signals, "guaranteed returns", or unregistered investment offers (ScamDeceptive). |
| Health tools | Allowed for software. Must not claim to diagnose, treat or cure without the approvals that would require (Misleading). |
| Security tools | Allowed for legitimate testing, defence and research tools from identifiable vendors. Not allowed for tools sold for unauthorized access (Malware). |
| Free and open-source tools | Welcome. The listing fee is the same. Editors may also list them as basic listings. |
| Products that are still early | Allowed if a real product can be used or bought today. A waitlist alone is SiteUnavailable. |
While a listing is live
- The site must keep meeting this policy. Listings are re-checked each month and when someone reports them.
- If a re-check finds high-severity sexual content, the listing is hidden at the next update until an admin decides. Anything else is flagged to an admin. Nothing else is hidden automatically.
- A website that changes owner or changes into something else counts as a new tool. The listing may be removed (
Mismatch). - A deal must link to the vendor's own domain, give a real saving, have an end date and follow this policy. Admins may hide any deal.
Decisions and reviews
- Paying the fee doesn't guarantee a listing. Neither paying nor saving a card means a listing will be accepted.
- Every listing is checked by automated review, including AI tools (Content Safety and an AI rubric). A person then decides. The automated result is advice only.
- The vendor is told the reason code and a short explanation for any decline or change request.
- A declined listing is final. The same website can be submitted again after 90 days, except for
SexualContentandMalware, which are permanent. A decline costs nothing, because the card is charged only on approval. - There is no appeal. ATBI's owners make the decisions, and there is no one above them to appeal to. A vendor who thinks we've made a mistake can reply to the decision email once, and we'll look at it again. What we decide then is final.
How the automated review uses this policy
- Content Safety "Sexual" severity of Medium or above on the site's text or images, the listing's text or its images is a hard
SexualContentrecommendation of Decline, whatever the AI rubric says. - Only deterministic checks recommend Decline: Content Safety's Sexual result, an adult top-level domain, a blocked domain, and a parked page the rubric agrees isn't software. The AI rubric can raise any code above, quoting the site as evidence, but a concern it raises only ever asks a person to look (NeedsHumanReview). It can't decline a listing by itself, and it can't overrule a failed check.
- Anything uncertain, including a site the review couldn't fetch, recommends NeedsHumanReview. The admin then chooses Approve, Request changes (for a "Must be true" rule) or Decline.
